| Season | Premiers/Promoted | Promotion/ Relegation Play-Off Final | Player of the Final |
| 2026 | Lake Macquarie City FC | Kahibah FC 2-1 Newcastle Croatia @ Hunter City Motor Group Stadium, Weston | Oskar Crakanthorp (Kahibah FC) |
| 2025 | Kahibah FC | Valentine FC 4-0 West Wallsend SFC @ Magic Park | Dean Pettit (Valentine FC) |
| 2024 | Belmont Swansea United | Adamstown Rosebud 3-2 Toronto Awaba FC @ Jack McLaughlan Oval | Dino Fajkovic (Adamstown Rosebud) |
| Season | Premiers | Champions | Grand Final | Player of the Grand Final |
| 2023 | Toronto Awaba FC | West Wallsend SFC | West Wallsend SFC 1-1 South Cardiff FC (4-2 on penalties) @ Johnston Park | |
| 2022 | New Lambton FC | Belmont Swansea United | New Lambton FC 1-2 Belmont Swansea United @ Jack McLaughlan Oval | |
| 2021 | New Lambton FC | Finals series cancelled due to COVID-19 | Finals series cancelled due to COVID-19 | |
| 2020 | New Lambton FC | Singleton Strikers | New Lambton FC 0-2 Singleton Strikers @ Magic Park | Joel Barner (Singleton Strikers) |
| 2019 | Cooks Hill United | Belmont Swansea United | Cooks Hill United 2-3 Belmont Swansea United @ Jack McLaughlan Oval | |
| 2018 | Cooks Hill United | Belmont Swansea United | West Wallsend SFC v Belmont Swansea United @ Macquarie Field | |
| 2017 | Cooks Hill United | Cooks Hill United | Cooks Hill United 4-0 Belmont Swansea United @ Magic Park | |
| 2016 | Lake Macquarie City FC | Wallsend FC | Wallsend FC 4-3 Belmont Swansea United on penalties @ Jack McLaughlan Oval | |
| 2015 | Valentine FC | Wallsend FC | Wallsend FC 1-0 Valentine FC @ Rockwell Automation Park | |
| 2014 | Maitland FC | Maitland FC | Maitland FC 1-1 Valentine FC @ Adamstown Oval (3-1 penalties) |